PadhaikoAll subjects

Cost

Engineering Economics (ENCE 356)

Open in the Padhaiko app

3.1 Cost classification

In engineering management and economic evaluation, cost represents the monetary value of resources consumed to design, manufacture, construct, operate, or support a product or system. Because different engineering decisions require different views of expenditure, costs are classified along functional, behavioral, traceability, and decision-relevance dimensions.

3.1.1 Total, average, fixed, variable, and marginal costs

Costs are categorized by how they respond to changes in the volume of output over a given planning horizon:

Definition

Fixed, Variable, and Total Cost

From total cost, four unit and incremental cost measures are derived:

  1. Average Fixed Cost (): Fixed cost spread over output :
  1. Average Variable Cost (): Variable cost per unit of output:
  1. Average Total Cost ( or ): Total cost per unit produced:
  1. Marginal Cost (): The additional cost incurred to produce one extra unit of output. Mathematically, it is the first derivative of (or ) with respect to :
Theorem

Relationship Between MC and ATC

The marginal cost curve intersects both the and curves at their respective minimum points:

3.1.2 Direct, indirect, and standard costs

For cost accounting and operational control, costs are grouped by traceability to a specific cost object (a product, batch, or engineering project) and by benchmarking role:

Direct, Indirect, and Standard Costs
Cost CategoryDefinitionEngineering Examples
Direct CostCosts that can be traced easily, accurately, and economically to a single product, department, or project.Structural steel for a bridge, PCB components for a router, direct assembly labor hours.
Indirect Cost (Overhead)Costs shared across multiple products or operations that cannot be traced directly to one unit without an allocation rule.Factory lighting, plant supervisor salaries, central server maintenance, security.
Standard CostA predetermined, engineered target unit cost established under normal efficient operating conditions before production begins.Standard material allowance ( at ) and standard labor time ().

3.1.3 Cash versus book cost, manufacturing and non-manufacturing cost

Cash Cost vs. Book Cost

AspectCash CostBook Cost
DefinitionInvolves an actual cash outflow or monetary transaction with an external party.Accounting charge recorded on financial books with no current cash transfer.
ExamplesWages paid, fuel purchased, supplier invoices, loan interest paid.Depreciation of machinery, amortization of patents, depletion allowances.
Role in Engineering EconomyEntered directly into Cash Flow Diagrams and NPV/IRR computations.Excluded directly from cash flows, except for its indirect effect on income taxes (tax shield).

Manufacturing vs. Non-Manufacturing Cost

In industrial firms, total operating outlays are divided into production (manufacturing) costs and commercial/administrative (non-manufacturing) costs:

  1. Manufacturing (Factory) Costs: All expenses required inside the production facility to convert raw materials into finished goods:
    • Direct Materials: Raw inputs physically forming part of the final product.
    • Direct Labor: Workforce hands-on converting materials into finished goods.
    • Manufacturing Overhead (Factory Burden): Indirect materials (lubricants, coolants), indirect labor (inspectors, maintenance crew), factory utilities, and plant depreciation.
    • Note: ; .
  2. Non-Manufacturing (Period) Costs: Expenses incurred outside the factory floor:
    • Selling and Distribution Costs: Advertising, sales commissions, shipping, warehousing of finished goods.
    • Administrative Costs: Executive management, accounting, human resources, legal compliance, corporate IT.

3.1.4 Sunk cost, opportunity cost, element of cost, life-cycle cost

Sunk Cost and Opportunity Cost

Definition

Sunk Cost vs. Opportunity Cost

Elements of Cost (Cost Build-Up Structure)

In engineering cost accounting, total cost and selling price are built sequentially through standard cost elements:

Cost Build-Up LadderText
  Direct Materials + Direct Labor + Direct Expenses
        = PRIME COST
            + Factory (Works) Overhead
        = FACTORY COST (Works Cost)
            + Office & Administrative Overhead
        = COST OF PRODUCTION
            + Selling & Distribution Overhead
        = TOTAL COST (Cost of Sales)
            + Profit Margin
        = SELLING PRICE

Life-Cycle Cost (LCC)

Definition

Life-Cycle Cost (LCC)

Life-Cycle Cost is the sum of all recurring and non-recurring costs associated with an engineering product, structure, or system over its entire lifespan—from initial conceptual design to final disposal ("cradle-to-grave").

The four phases of Life-Cycle Costing are:

  1. Acquisition / Design Phase: Research and development, engineering design, prototyping, testing, and capital procurement.
  2. Installation & Commissioning: Site preparation, transport, setup, and operator training.
  3. Operation & Maintenance (O&M) Phase: Energy consumption, labor, routine maintenance, spare parts, and downtime losses (often exceeding initial purchase price over 10–20 years).
  4. Disposal / Decommissioning Phase: Dismantling, environmental remediation, minus any salvage value recovered.

Designing slightly higher upfront efficiency (e.g., premium-efficiency electric motors or thermal insulation) often raises acquisition cost slightly while dramatically lowering total Life-Cycle Cost.


3.2 Cost estimation and control

Reliable cost estimation translates technical specifications into realistic financial budgets before capital is committed, while cost control tracks actual expenditures against those baselines during execution.

Types of Cost Estimates by Project Phase

  1. Order-of-Magnitude (Rough) Estimate ( to ): Prepared during early feasibility screening using historical ratios or capacity scaling.
  2. Preliminary (Budget) Estimate ( to ): Prepared once basic engineering layouts and equipment sizes are selected.
  3. Definitive (Detailed) Estimate ( to ): Built bottom-up from detailed Bills of Materials (BOM), vendor quotations, labor hours, and subcontractor bids.

Quantitative Cost Estimation Models

  1. Per-Unit Model: Estimates cost by multiplying a standard unit cost factor by project scale (e.g., construction cost per square meter, highway cost per lane-kilometer).
  2. Segmenting (Unit-Rate / Bottom-Up) Model: Breaks the project into work packages (earthwork, concrete, cabling, testing), estimates each independently, and sums them.
  3. Cost Index Model (Time/Inflation Adjustment): Adjusts historical equipment cost from reference year to target year using a published price/cost index :
  1. Power-Sizing (Capacity Scaling) Model: Accounts for economies of scale when scaling plant or equipment capacity from to using an empirical scaling exponent (typically for industrial process equipment, known as the "six-tenths rule"):
  1. Learning Curve Model: Reflects productivity gains in repetitive manufacturing—each time cumulative production doubles, the labor hours (or unit cost) required per unit falls by a fixed learning percentage (), following:

where is the time for the first unit and is the time for the -th unit.

Cost Control Principles

Effective engineering cost control closes the feedback loop during project execution:


Worked Examples

Example 1

1

A precision component manufacturer operates with the short-run total cost function:

where is daily output in units and is in rupees.

  1. Identify the Fixed Cost (), Variable Cost (), and Marginal Cost () functions.
  2. At an output of units, compute , , , , and .
  3. Determine the output level that minimizes Average Total Cost (), and find the minimum .

Extracting cost functions:

  • The constant term independent of is Fixed Cost: .
  • The output-dependent terms form Variable Cost: .
  • Differentiating with respect to gives Marginal Cost:

Evaluating cost metrics at :

Since , average total cost is still declining at .

Finding the minimum :

Equating :

Substituting gives:

Example 2

2

For a monthly production batch of industrial switchgear, a factory records the following costs:

Construct the cost sheet to find Prime Cost, Factory Cost, Cost of Production, Total Cost, and the required Selling Price if the firm targets a profit margin on the selling price.

Computing Prime Cost and Factory Cost:

Computing Cost of Production and Total Cost:

Determining Selling Price for a margin on selling price:

Example 3

3

In 2020, a municipal utility installed a booster pump station for when the national Engineering Cost Index stood at . Management now plans to build a larger pump station when the cost index is . Using a power-sizing exponent of , estimate the capital cost of the new station.

Combining power-sizing and cost-index scaling:

Computing the estimated cost: First evaluate the capacity ratio factor:

Next evaluate the cost index multiplier:

Multiplying by the reference cost:

Because of economies of scale (), increasing capacity by increases constant-index cost by only , before adjusting upward for price inflation.


Exercises

added

Question 1

Distinguish between cash cost and book cost, and explain why sunk costs are excluded from engineering economic comparisons while opportunity costs must be included.

Comparing Cash Cost vs. Book Cost:

  • Cash costs involve actual monetary outlays (wages, materials, energy bills) and enter cash flow tables directly.
  • Book costs (such as depreciation) are accounting entries representing historical asset consumption; they involve no cash movement in the current period and affect economic cash flow analysis only indirectly through income tax deductions.

Decision relevance of Sunk vs. Opportunity Costs:

  • Sunk costs occurred in the past and cannot be changed by any present choice; because they remain identical across all future alternatives, including them biases decisions.
  • Opportunity costs measure the highest net return foregone by committing a limited resource (such as existing land or machine time) to a project rather than its best alternative use; ignoring them understates true project cost.
Answer:

Cash costs reflect real cash transfers whereas book costs are non-cash accounting charges (affecting cash flow only via tax shields). Sunk costs are unrecoverable past outlays common to all future options and must be excluded; opportunity costs represent foregone prospective returns from alternative resource uses and must be included.

Question 2

A fabrication shop has the total cost function .

  1. At units, compute Fixed Cost, Variable Cost, Average Total Cost (), and Marginal Cost ().
  2. Find the exact output level (to two decimal places) that minimizes .

Evaluating costs at :

Differentiating gives , so:

Finding for minimum : Set :

Answer:

At : , , , . Minimum occurs at units.

Question 3

The cost records of an electrical panel assembler show: Direct Materials , Direct Labor , Direct Expenses , Factory Overhead , Office Overhead , and Selling Overhead . Calculate Prime Cost, Factory Cost, Total Cost, and Selling Price with a profit markup on Total Cost.

Computing Prime Cost and Factory Cost:

Computing Total Cost and Selling Price:

Answer:

Prime Cost ; Factory Cost ; Total Cost ; Selling Price .

Question 4
  1. A water treatment plant cost . Estimate the cost of a plant using a power-sizing exponent of (assuming constant price index).
  2. In an assembly line with an learning curve, the first complex drone airframe requires . Estimate the labor-hours required for the unit.

Applying the power-sizing model:

Applying the learning curve for unit : Because represents two doublings of cumulative production (), each doubling multiplies unit hours by the learning rate:

(Equivalently, , so .)

Answer:
  1. Estimated cost of the plant: .
  2. Labor-hours for the unit: hours.
Question 5

Define Life-Cycle Cost (LCC) and explain its four main cost phases. Why can selecting the machine with the lowest purchase price result in higher total life-cycle cost?

Defining Life-Cycle Cost and its four phases: Life-Cycle Cost is the cumulative total cost of an engineered asset from initial conception to retirement ("cradle-to-grave"):

  1. Design & Acquisition: R&D, engineering, capital purchase price.
  2. Installation & Commissioning: Delivery, civil works, testing, initial training.
  3. Operation & Maintenance (O&M): Energy, fuel, labor, spare parts, scheduled overhauls.
  4. Disposal / Decommissioning: Dismantling and environmental cleanup, net of salvage recovery.

Why lowest purchase price can yield higher LCC: Purchase price represents only the acquisition phase. A cheap motor, boiler, or server rack with lower efficiency or lower component reliability often consumes substantially more electricity and requires frequent repairs over a - to -year operating life. When discounted over time, these elevated O&M expenses frequently outweigh the initial purchase savings, producing a higher total LCC.

Answer:

Life-Cycle Cost sums all cradle-to-grave costs across acquisition, installation, O&M, and net disposal. A low-purchase-price asset can incur much higher energy, maintenance, and downtime expenses over its operating life, resulting in a higher total LCC than a higher-efficiency alternative.

← Market EconomicsTime Value of Money →