Past exam question: 2072 Chaitra, Q7
Open in the Padhaiko appQuestion
Differentiate between circuit switching and packet switching with suitable diagram.
Solution
Fundamental Architectures and Diagrams: In telecommunication networks, switching techniques establish data transfer paths between source and destination stations.
1. Circuit Switching:
Host A === [ Dedicated Physical Path Established ] === Host B
Stages: 1. Call Setup --> 2. Data Transmission --> 3. Call Teardown
2. Packet Switching:
Host A ---> [Packet 1] ---> Node 1 ---> Node 3 ---\
---> [Packet 2] ---> Node 2 ---> Node 3 ----> Host B (Reassembled)
(Shared links, store-and-forward at intermediate switches)
- Circuit Switching: A dedicated physical communications channel (end-to-end path) is established between the two communicating stations before data transfer begins. The bandwidth and resources remain reserved exclusively for the duration of the session.
- Packet Switching: Data is divided into discrete, addressed chunks called packets. Each packet travels independently through network nodes using store-and-forward routing across shared communication links.
Key Comparative Parameters:
| Parameter | Circuit Switching | Packet Switching |
|---|---|---|
| Dedicated Path | Yes, established prior to transfer. | No, dynamic routing over shared links. |
| Call Setup Phase | Mandatory (adds initial connection setup delay). | Not required (connectionless datagram mode). |
| Bandwidth Utilization | Low (resources reserved even during silent periods). | High (statistical multiplexing shares bandwidth dynamically). |
| Transmission Delay | Constant transmission delay once setup; zero queuing delay. | Variable delay due to queuing and store-and-forward processing. |
| Congestion Behavior | Call blocking at setup time; no congestion during data phase. | Packets experience queuing delays or packet dropping when congested. |
| Best Suited For | Continuous, real-time voice and video streams. | Burst-type data communications (web traffic, email, file transfers). |
Answer:
Circuit switching establishes a dedicated end-to-end physical path before communication (setup, transfer, teardown), giving constant delay but wasting idle bandwidth (e.g., PSTN). Packet switching splits data into addressed packets forwarded independently via store-and-forward routers without reserving a fixed circuit, giving high link utilization and variable queuing delay (e.g., Internet).