Past exam question: 2074 Ashwin, Q1(b)
Open in the Padhaiko appQuestion
Compare analog communication system with digital communication system with appropriate block diagram for half-duplex mode.
Solution
Half-Duplex Digital Communication System Block Diagram: In half-duplex (HDX) mode, both stations can transmit and receive, but only one station can transmit at any given instant. A Transmit/Receive (T/R) switch alternates the shared channel between the transmitter and receiver chains:
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| STATION A |
| |
| [ Source ] ---> [ Source Enc ] ---> [ Channel Enc ] ---> [ Modulator ] |
| | |
| v |
| [ T/R Switch ] |
| ^ | |
| | v |
| [ Sink ] <--- [ Source Dec ] <--- [ Channel Dec ] <--- [ Demodulator ] |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------|-----+
|
================
Shared Channel
================
|
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------|-----+
| STATION B v |
| [ T/R Switch ] |
| | ^ |
| v | |
| [ Sink ] <--- [ Source Dec ] <--- [ Channel Dec ] <--- [ Demodulator ] |
| |
| [ Source ] ---> [ Source Enc ] ---> [ Channel Enc ] ---> [ Modulator ] |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+Comparison Between Analog and Digital Systems:
| Dimension | Analog Communication System | Digital Communication System |
|---|---|---|
| Signal Form | Continuously varying physical waveforms | Discrete binary pulses ( and ) |
| Noise Accumulation | Noise compounds monotonically with link distance at every amplifier | Completely halted by regenerative repeaters, which re-emit fresh pulses |
| Error Handling | None | Powerful forward error correction (CRC, Hamming) |
| Security | Minimal (voice scrambling is easily intercepted) | Advanced cryptographic encryption (AES, RSA) |
| Bandwidth | Conserves bandwidth (e.g., analog speech) | Consumes higher channel bandwidth ( PCM) |
| Multiplexing | Frequency Division Multiplexing (FDM) | Time Division Multiplexing (TDM), packet switching |
Answer:
In half-duplex mode, communication occurs in both directions alternately using a T/R switch over a shared channel.
- Digital systems provide superior noise immunity (via regenerative repeaters), robust forward error correction (FEC), and cryptographic security, but require higher bandwidth.
- Analog systems consume less bandwidth and avoid complex A/D conversion, but suffer from cumulative noise and lack error-correction capabilities.