Entanglement and Quantum Communication
Open in the Padhaiko app3.1 Entangled states and Bell theorem
Quantum entanglement is the quintessential phenomenon of quantum mechanics that distinguishes it from all classical theories. Two or more physical systems are said to be entangled when their joint quantum state cannot be expressed as a separable product of the individual states of the subsystems, regardless of the spatial separation between them.
The Four Bell States (EPR Pairs)
For a bipartite two-qubit system in , the four Bell states (or EPR pairs) form an orthonormal basis of maximally entangled states:
The Four Bell States (Bell Basis)
The four maximally entangled Bell basis vectors are defined as:
- State:
- State:
- State (Triplet state, ):
- State (Singlet state):
These states satisfy the orthonormality condition and form a complete resolution of the four-dimensional identity operator: .
Bell's Theorem and the CHSH Inequality
In 1964, John Stewart Bell established one of the most profound theorems in modern physics:
Bell's Theorem and the CHSH Inequality
Bell's Theorem: No physical theory of local hidden variables can ever reproduce all the statistical predictions of quantum mechanics.
To test this experimentally, Clauser, Horne, Shimony, and Holt (CHSH) formulated an experimentally testable inequality. Consider two spatially separated observers, Alice and Bob. Alice can choose between two measurement settings and , and Bob can choose between and , where each measurement yields an outcome :
- Classical Local Hidden-Variable Bound: Under the assumptions of locality (Alice's measurement choice cannot instantaneously affect Bob's outcome) and realism (measurement outcomes are pre-determined by hidden variables ), the CHSH correlation parameter is strictly bounded:
- Quantum Tsirelson's Bound: Quantum mechanics allows the correlation parameter to violate the classical bound up to Tsirelson's bound:
For the Bell state , setting Alice's observables to and Bob's observables to yields:
This experimental violation decisively refutes local realism.
3.2 EPR paradox
In 1935, Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky, and Nathan Rosen (EPR) published their historic paper questioning whether the quantum-mechanical description of physical reality can be considered complete.
The EPR Argument
The EPR argument is constructed upon two core premises:
- Criterion of Physical Reality: If, without in any way disturbing a system, we can predict with certainty (i.e., with probability equal to unity) the value of a physical quantity, then there exists an element of physical reality corresponding to that quantity.
- Principle of Locality: Physical events occurring at spatial point cannot instantaneously affect physical reality at a distant spatial point (Einstein locality / no faster-than-light influence).
Consider an entangled singlet state shared between Alice and Bob:
If Alice measures her particle along the -axis and observes (state ), she knows with certainty that Bob will obtain (state ) if he measures along the -axis. Because Alice did not disturb Bob's distant particle, the value of Bob's -spin must have been an element of reality.
Alternatively, if Alice chooses to measure her particle along the -axis, she can predict with certainty Bob's -spin. Because Alice can choose to measure either observable without disturbing Bob, both the -spin and -spin of Bob's particle must simultaneously be elements of physical reality. But in quantum mechanics, non-commuting observables () cannot have simultaneous definite values. Hence, EPR concluded that quantum mechanics is incomplete and that "hidden variables" must exist to describe the complete state of physical systems.
| Aspect | Local Realism (EPR Viewpoint) | Quantum Non-Locality (Copenhagen Viewpoint) |
|---|---|---|
| Physical Reality | Physical properties exist with definite values prior to measurement | Properties are fundamentally indeterminate until actualized by measurement |
| Completeness | Quantum wavefunctions are incomplete statistical representations | The state vector provides the complete description of reality |
| Entangled Correlation | Explained by pre-existing local hidden variables | Inherent non-local quantum correlations governed by joint state vectors |
| Experimental Verdict | Definitively ruled out by experimental violations of Bell/CHSH tests | Validated by Aspect (1982), Zeilinger, and loophole-free Bell tests (2015) |
Resolution and the No-Signaling Theorem
Quantum mechanics resolves the EPR paradox by accepting that reality is fundamentally non-local in its correlations, yet strictly compatible with relativistic causality via the No-Signaling Theorem:
Let a bipartite density operator be . Bob's local physical state is described entirely by his reduced density operator:
If Alice performs a local measurement using complete measurement operators (), the post-measurement state from Bob's perspective is:
Bob's local density matrix remains completely unchanged by Alice's actions. Therefore, quantum entanglement cannot be used to transmit classical information faster than the speed of light.
3.3 Quantum teleportation and superdense coding
Quantum teleportation and superdense coding represent two complementary paradigms of quantum communication, illustrating the trade-off between quantum and classical communication resources in the presence of shared entanglement.
Quantum Teleportation
Quantum Teleportation Protocol
Quantum Teleportation (Bennett et al., 1993) is a protocol that transmits an unknown single-qubit quantum state:
from sender Alice to distant receiver Bob, by consuming one shared Bell pair and transmitting two classical bits over a classical communication channel.
Step-by-Step Protocol:
- Shared Entangled Pair: Alice and Bob initially share an entangled Bell state . Alice holds qubit , Bob holds qubit , and Alice holds the unknown state qubit ().
- Total Initial State ( qubits):
- Alice's Local Operations (Bell Measurement):
- Alice applies with control qubit and target qubit :
- Alice applies a Hadamard gate to qubit :
- Measurement and Classical Transmission: Alice measures her two qubits in the computational basis, obtaining one of four random outcomes with equal probability : or . She sends these classical bits to Bob over a standard telephone or fiber-optic line.
- Bob's Unitary Correction: Upon receiving Alice's two bits, Bob applies the corresponding unitary recovery operation to his qubit :
- If Alice sent : Bob applies .
- If Alice sent : Bob applies .
- If Alice sent : Bob applies .
- If Alice sent : Bob applies .
Notice that the unknown state is never measured or cloned: Alice's measurement destroys her local copy, satisfying the No-Cloning theorem.
Superdense Coding
Superdense Coding Protocol
Superdense Coding (Bennett and Wiesner, 1992) is the dual protocol to teleportation: it transmits two classical bits of information from Alice to Bob by sending only one physical qubit, using one pre-shared Bell pair.
Step-by-Step Protocol:
- Alice and Bob share the Bell pair .
- Alice encodes two classical bits by applying a single-qubit unitary gate to her qubit:
- To send : Alice applies
- To send : Alice applies
- To send : Alice applies
- To send : Alice applies
- Alice transmits her single physical qubit to Bob across a quantum channel.
- Bob now possesses both qubits. He performs a Bell basis measurement:
- Bob applies with Alice's qubit as control and his qubit as target.
- Bob applies a Hadamard gate to Alice's qubit.
- Bob measures both qubits in the computational basis, deterministically retrieving with accuracy.
3.4 Quantum key distribution protocols: BB84, E91
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) enables two communicating parties, Alice and Bob, to establish an unconditionally secure, shared random cryptographic key guaranteed by the laws of quantum mechanics.
The BB84 Protocol (Prepare-and-Measure)
Invented by Charles Bennett and Gilles Brassard in 1984, BB84 utilizes single photons polarized in two mutually unbiased bases (MUBs):
- Rectilinear Basis (): (e.g., horizontal and vertical ).
- Diagonal Basis (): (e.g., and ), where and .
The BB84 Protocol Execution:
- Quantum Transmission: Alice generates a random bit sequence. For each bit, she randomly chooses either the or basis and prepares a single photon:
- In basis : Bit , Bit .
- In basis : Bit , Bit . She transmits the photon train to Bob over an optical fiber or free-space channel.
- Measurement: For each incoming photon, Bob independently chooses at random to measure in either the or basis and records his measurement outcome.
- Sifting Phase: Over a public classical authenticated channel, Alice and Bob announce the basis they used for each photon. They discard all bits where their basis choices differed. Because each party chooses between two bases with equal probability, they retain approximately of the transmitted bits, called the sifted key.
- Eavesdropping Detection & QBER: Alice and Bob openly compare a randomly chosen subset of the sifted key bits to calculate the Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER):
If Eve attempts an intercept-resend attack, by the uncertainty principle she will choose the wrong basis of the time and induce an error rate of in the sifted key. If (the Shor-Preskill security bound), Alice and Bob proceed to classical error correction and privacy amplification; if , they abort the protocol.
The E91 Protocol (Entanglement-Based)
Proposed by Artur Ekert in 1991, E91 relies on quantum entanglement and the violation of Bell's inequality:
- An entangled source produces EPR singlet pairs and distributes one particle to Alice and one to Bob.
- Alice and Bob each choose measurement orientations from sets of three angles:
- Alice's analyzer angles: .
- Bob's analyzer angles: .
- Sifting and Verification:
- Compatible Settings ( and ): Their measurement orientations match. Because exhibits perfect anti-correlation, Alice's outcome is always the exact opposite of Bob's (). Inverting Bob's bits produces the secret key.
- Incompatible Settings: Used to compute the CHSH correlation parameter . If the measurement statistics yield , the entanglement is verified to be pure and maximal. By the monogamy of entanglement, a maximally entangled pair cannot be entangled with any third system (Eve), guaranteeing absolute information-theoretic security.
| Feature | BB84 Protocol | E91 Protocol |
|---|---|---|
| Inventor & Year | Charles Bennett & Gilles Brassard (1984) | Artur Ekert (1991) |
| Physical Mechanism | Prepare-and-measure single photon states | Entanglement distribution of EPR pairs |
| Bases / Orientations | Two mutually unbiased bases ( and ) | Three analyzer angles per observer |
| Security Foundation | Quantum No-Cloning & Heisenberg Uncertainty | Bell's Theorem & Monogamy of Entanglement |
| Eavesdropper Test | Statistical error checking () | Violation of CHSH inequality () |
Worked Examples
3.1
Consider the maximally entangled state . Alice measures observables and . Bob measures observables and .
- Calculate the expectation values and .
- Compute the CHSH correlation parameter and show that it achieves Tsirelson's bound .
Evaluating Expectation Values with Pauli Observables: For the state , we evaluate the standard two-qubit expectation values:
- : , . Hence .
- : , . Hence .
- : , . Because and , .
- Similarly, .
Computing Alice and Bob Correlation Terms: Using linearity of expectation values:
Evaluating the CHSH Parameter : Summing the terms according to the CHSH expression:
Because , this calculation demonstrates a maximal violation of the classical CHSH inequality .
- Individual expectations: , , ,
- CHSH Parameter: , which strictly exceeds the local realistic limit and matches Tsirelson's quantum bound.
3.2
In the quantum teleportation protocol, Alice wants to teleport the quantum state:
using a pre-shared Bell pair .
- Calculate the probability of Alice measuring the outcome on her two qubits.
- What state does Bob hold immediately upon Alice's measurement of ?
- What unitary operation must Bob apply to recover ?
Probability of Alice's Measurement Outcomes: In the quantum teleportation circuit, Alice's measurement on qubits projects the combined state onto one of the four computational basis states: or . As proven in Section 3.3, each measurement outcome occurs with identical probability:
This probability is independent of the amplitudes and .
Bob's State for Measurement Outcome : From the teleportation identity, the post-measurement state corresponding to is:
Bob's Unitary Correction: To eliminate the phase on , Bob applies the Pauli-Z gate:
- Probability of outcome :
- Bob's state immediately after Alice's measurement:
- Unitary correction: Pauli-Z gate (), restoring .
3.3
In the superdense coding protocol, Alice and Bob share the Bell pair . Alice wishes to send the classical two-bit message .
- Specify the local quantum gate Alice must apply to her qubit.
- Write down the two-qubit state after Alice's encoding.
- Trace Bob's decoding circuit to show that the message is decoded with certainty.
Alice's Encoding Operation: According to the standard superdense coding encoding table:
- Message
- Message
- Message
- Message
For message , Alice applies the Pauli- gate to her qubit (qubit 1).
State After Alice's Encoding: Applying to :
Tracing Bob's Decoding Steps: After Alice sends her qubit to Bob, Bob applies:
- with qubit 1 as control and qubit 2 as target:
- For : control is , target , yielding .
- For : control is , target , yielding . So .
- Hadamard gate on qubit 1:
Measuring both qubits in the computational basis yields the exact two-bit message with probability .
- Alice's gate: Pauli- gate ()
- Encoded state:
- Decoding: Bob applies then , yielding and measuring the transmitted bits with certainty.
Practice Exercises
Practice Exercises — Entanglement and Quantum Communication
Prove that the Bell states and are strictly orthogonal by computing their inner product .
Expressing Bra and Ket Vectors: The bra vector for is:
The ket vector for is:
Evaluating the Inner Product: Expanding the product:
Using the orthonormality of the computational basis ():
, proving that and are strictly orthogonal in .
Determine whether the two-qubit state:
is an entangled state or a separable product state. Justify your answer by factoring the state into a tensor product of single-qubit states.
Factoring the State Vector: Grouping terms in :
Factoring out :
Expressing as Product State: Recognizing that :
Because can be written as where and , there is no entanglement between the qubits.
The state is separable (product state):
Because it factors cleanly into independent single-qubit states, its degree of entanglement is zero.
In the BB84 protocol, calculate the theoretical Quantum Bit Error Rate () introduced into the sifted key if an eavesdropper (Eve) performs an intercept-resend attack on every single photon.
Probability of Basis Mismatch by Eve: For each photon, Alice chooses basis or with equal probability . Eve intercepts the photon and must guess a measurement basis:
- Probability that Eve chooses the correct basis .
- Probability that Eve chooses the wrong basis .
Conditional Error Probability for Bob: We analyze only the sifted key (photons where Alice and Bob selected the same basis):
- If Eve picked the correct basis (prob ): She measures the photon without disturbance and resends the exact state Alice prepared. Bob measures in the matching basis and obtains the correct bit with probability . Error .
- If Eve picked the wrong basis (prob ): She projects the photon into an orthogonal basis state (e.g., preparing when Alice sent ). When Bob measures in Alice's basis , he obtains with probability and with probability . Thus, Bob gets an incorrect bit with probability .
Total Sifted Key Error Rate (): Using the law of total probability:
The theoretical error rate is (or ). Because vastly exceeds the security threshold, Alice and Bob easily detect Eve's presence and abort the key.
State the No-Cloning Theorem and provide its formal mathematical proof using the unitarity of quantum evolution.
Theorem Statement: The No-Cloning Theorem (Wootters & Zurek, 1982; Dieks, 1982) states that it is impossible to create an identical copy of an arbitrary, unknown quantum state. That is, there does not exist any unitary operator capable of performing the transformation:
for all possible state vectors , where is a fixed standard blank state.
Proof by Contradiction: Suppose such a unitary cloning operator exists. Then for two arbitrary distinct quantum states and :
Taking the inner product of the left-hand sides:
Taking the inner product of the right-hand sides:
Evaluating the Contradiction: Equating both inner products gives:
This algebraic equation has only two solutions:
- : The states are strictly orthogonal.
- : The states are identical ().
Therefore, a unitary cloner can only clone states that are mutually orthogonal. An arbitrary unknown quantum state cannot be cloned.
The No-Cloning Theorem proves that , meaning only identical or orthogonal states could be copied. Hence, a universal cloner for arbitrary quantum states is forbidden by the linearity and unitarity of quantum mechanics.
Suppose in quantum teleportation, Alice and Bob share the Bell state instead of . If Alice applies the standard Bell measurement circuit ( then ), derive the unitary corrections Bob must apply for each of the four classical outcomes .
Initial Three-Qubit State: With unknown state and shared state :
Applying Alice's Gates ( and ):
- flips qubit when qubit is :
- maps and :
Determining Bob's Required Corrections: Matching each outcome to :
- Outcome : Bob holds . To recover , Bob applies .
- Outcome : Bob holds . Bob applies .
- Outcome : Bob holds . Bob applies (or ).
- Outcome : Bob holds . Bob applies .
Bob's required unitary corrections:
- For outcome : Apply
- For outcome : Apply
- For outcome : Apply
- For outcome : Apply