Past exam question: Assignment 3, Q1
Open in the Padhaiko appDifferentiate between open loop and closed loop instrumentation system along with block diagrams.
Solution
Block Diagrams of Open-Loop and Closed-Loop Instrumentation Systems: In an open-loop system, the output is neither measured nor fed back to modify the input; in a closed-loop system, a feedback sensor compares the actual output with the desired reference (setpoint) to drive an error-correcting controller:
(a) Open-Loop Instrumentation System:
+-----------+ +------------+ +---------------+ +-----------+
| Input / |---->| Controller |---->| Process / |---->| Output |
| Setpoint | | (No error | | Actuator | | (Variable)|
+-----------+ | check) | +---------------+ +-----------+
+------------+
(b) Closed-Loop (Feedback) Instrumentation System:
e(t) = r(t) - b(t)
+-----------+ (+) +------------+ +-----------+ +-----------+
| Reference |---->( )---->| Controller |---->| Process / |---->| Output |
| Input r(t)| (-) | | | Actuator | | | c(t) |
+-----------+ ^ +------------+ +-----------+ | +-----------+
| |
| b(t) +--------------------+ |
+------------| Feedback Sensor / |<-----+
| Transducer |
+--------------------+Point-by-Point Comparison:
| Aspect | Open-Loop System | Closed-Loop System |
|---|---|---|
| Feedback Path | Absent; output does not influence input action. | Present; output is measured and fed back to the comparator. |
| Error Detection | No error detector; cannot sense external disturbances. | Error detector computes continuously. |
| Accuracy & Disturbance Rejection | Sensitive to load variations, calibration drift, and noise; requires periodic manual recalibration. | High accuracy; automatically compensates for external disturbances and parameter drift. |
| Stability & Complexity | Simple, low-cost hardware and always stable (no oscillation from feedback). | More complex and costly; high loop gain or phase lag can cause instability/oscillation. |
| Speed of Response | Fast (no feedback lag). | Slightly slower due to sensor and feedback processing delay. |
| Typical Examples | Bread toaster, traffic light on fixed timer, electric hand dryer, basic room heater without thermostat. | Thermostat-controlled heater, automatic temperature/pressure process loop, cruise control, servo positioning. |
An open-loop instrumentation system operates without output feedback (simple, low-cost, inherently stable, but sensitive to disturbances and calibration drift), whereas a closed-loop system feeds the measured output back to a comparator to minimize error (high accuracy and disturbance rejection, at the expense of higher complexity, cost, and potential stability concerns).