PadhaikoAll subjects

Past exam question: Assignment 3, Q1

Instrumentation · 4 marks

Open in the Padhaiko app

Topic: Introduction

Question

Differentiate between open loop and closed loop instrumentation system along with block diagrams.

Solution

Block Diagrams of Open-Loop and Closed-Loop Instrumentation Systems: In an open-loop system, the output is neither measured nor fed back to modify the input; in a closed-loop system, a feedback sensor compares the actual output with the desired reference (setpoint) to drive an error-correcting controller:

Open-Loop vs. Closed-Loop Instrumentation System Block DiagramsText
(a) Open-Loop Instrumentation System:
+-----------+     +------------+     +---------------+     +-----------+
|  Input /  |---->| Controller |---->|  Process /    |---->|  Output   |
|  Setpoint |     | (No error  |     |  Actuator     |     | (Variable)|
+-----------+     |  check)    |     +---------------+     +-----------+
                  +------------+

(b) Closed-Loop (Feedback) Instrumentation System:
                  e(t) = r(t) - b(t)
+-----------+     (+)     +------------+     +-----------+     +-----------+
| Reference |---->( )---->| Controller |---->| Process / |---->|  Output   |
| Input r(t)|     (-)     |            |     | Actuator  |  |  |   c(t)    |
+-----------+      ^      +------------+     +-----------+  |  +-----------+
                   |                                        |
                   |  b(t)      +--------------------+      |
                   +------------|  Feedback Sensor / |<-----+
                                |  Transducer        |
                                +--------------------+

Point-by-Point Comparison:

AspectOpen-Loop SystemClosed-Loop System
Feedback PathAbsent; output does not influence input action.Present; output is measured and fed back to the comparator.
Error DetectionNo error detector; cannot sense external disturbances.Error detector computes continuously.
Accuracy & Disturbance RejectionSensitive to load variations, calibration drift, and noise; requires periodic manual recalibration.High accuracy; automatically compensates for external disturbances and parameter drift.
Stability & ComplexitySimple, low-cost hardware and always stable (no oscillation from feedback).More complex and costly; high loop gain or phase lag can cause instability/oscillation.
Speed of ResponseFast (no feedback lag).Slightly slower due to sensor and feedback processing delay.
Typical ExamplesBread toaster, traffic light on fixed timer, electric hand dryer, basic room heater without thermostat.Thermostat-controlled heater, automatic temperature/pressure process loop, cruise control, servo positioning.
Answer:

An open-loop instrumentation system operates without output feedback (simple, low-cost, inherently stable, but sensitive to disturbances and calibration drift), whereas a closed-loop system feeds the measured output back to a comparator to minimize error (high accuracy and disturbance rejection, at the expense of higher complexity, cost, and potential stability concerns).

All past exam questions for Instrumentation