PadhaikoAll subjects

Past exam question: Assignment 3, Q21

Instrumentation · 4 marks

Open in the Padhaiko app

Topic: Connectivity Technology in Instrumentation System

Question

Compare lossy & lossless system.

Solution

Concept in Data Archiving and Compression: In instrumentation data logging and transmission, compression reduces storage footprint and network bandwidth. Depending on whether exact bit-for-bit reconstruction is required, systems are classified as lossless or lossy.

Comparison Table (Lossy vs. Lossless System):

AspectLossy SystemLossless System
Data ReconstructionApproximate; discarded information cannot be recovered after decompression.Exact bit-for-bit reconstruction identical to the original input.
MechanismRemoves perceptually or analytically minor detail (e.g., rounding 6.666666 7, quantization, transform coding).Exploits statistical redundancy without introducing error (e.g., Huffman, LZ77, RLE, delta encoding).
Compression RatioHigh ( to ), yielding very small files and low bandwidth use.Moderate ( to ), bounded by signal entropy.
Signal FidelityIntroduces controlled distortion / quantization error.Zero distortion; mathematical fidelity preserved.
Common FormatsJPEG (images), MP3/AAC (audio), MPEG/H.264 (video).ZIP/GZIP, PNG, FLAC, raw CSV/binary delta logs.
Instrumentation UseRemote camera/multimedia WSN monitoring, audio/vibration previews where slight loss is tolerable.Precision sensor logs, calibration tables, medical ECG/EEG records, financial/legal audit trails, executable firmware.
Answer:

A lossless system exploits statistical redundancy to achieve moderate compression () with exact bit-for-bit recovery (essential for precision sensor logs, calibration tables, and medical waveforms), whereas a lossy system achieves much higher compression () by permanently discarding minor details where slight fidelity loss is acceptable (suited to multimedia WSN image, audio, and video streams).

All past exam questions for Instrumentation