Photon and Matter Waves
Open in the Padhaiko app8.1 Quantum physics
Constants used: , , , , .
8.1.1 Inadequacy of classical mechanics, rise of quantum mechanics and quantization of energy
Classical mechanics and electromagnetism fail at atomic scales. The decisive failures were:
| Phenomenon | Classical prediction | Quantum resolution |
|---|---|---|
| Blackbody radiation | Rayleigh-Jeans law gives infinite energy at short wavelength (ultraviolet catastrophe) | Planck: energy is emitted in quanta |
| Photoelectric effect | Emission should depend on intensity, with a time lag and no threshold frequency | Einstein: light is photons of energy ; |
| Compton effect | Scattered wavelength should equal incident wavelength | Photon has momentum ; collisions shift |
| Atomic spectra and stability | Orbiting electrons should radiate and spiral into the nucleus; spectra should be continuous | Bohr: discrete energy levels, |
Quantization of energy. Planck's postulate: an oscillator of frequency can have only energies () and absorbs or emits energy in packets (quanta) of . Light of frequency consists of photons with
Einstein's photoelectric equation is , where is the work function and the stopping potential.
8.1.2 Group velocity, phase velocity, electrons and matter waves
Phase Velocity and Group Velocity
For a wave with :
- Phase velocity (speed of a point of constant phase): .
- Group velocity (speed of the envelope of a wave packet, which carries energy): .
They are related by the Rayleigh formula . In a non-dispersive medium .
A localized particle is represented by a wave packet, a superposition of waves of slightly different . For a particle of energy and momentum , the packet moves with the particle's velocity:
For a relativistic particle gives , so . This does not violate relativity because the phase velocity carries no energy or information.
8.1.3 de Broglie wavelength and its applications
de Broglie Hypothesis
Every moving particle of momentum has an associated wave of wavelength
For a particle of kinetic energy : . For an electron accelerated from rest through potential difference :
For a gas particle at temperature , .
Applications and evidence. Davisson and Germer observed electron diffraction from a nickel crystal (the Bragg law with ), and G. P. Thomson from thin foils. The wave nature is used in the electron microscope (a beam has , which gives resolution far beyond light microscopes) and in neutron diffraction for crystal and magnetic structure. For ordinary objects is far too small to observe (a ball at has ).
8.1.4 Heisenberg uncertainty principle and its applications
Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle
It is impossible to measure the position and momentum of a particle (or the energy and time) simultaneously with unlimited precision:
(Many textbooks write the bound as or ; the order of magnitude is what matters.) The limit is a property of the wave nature of matter and not a failure of instruments.
Applications.
- No electron in the nucleus: confining an electron in requires , i.e. energy of about , far more than the binding energies seen in beta decay. Electrons cannot be nuclear constituents.
- Zero-point energy: a confined particle cannot be at rest, so the lowest energy of an oscillator or a particle in a box is non-zero.
- Natural line width: an excited state of lifetime has energy spread .
- Size and stability of the atom: the minimum energy balance of kinetic () and Coulomb energy gives the Bohr radius.
8.1.5 Wave functions and their significance
The state of a particle is described by a wave function , which is generally complex and has no direct physical meaning. Its significance lies in Born's interpretation:
- is the probability density: is the probability of finding the particle in volume .
- Normalization: (the particle is somewhere).
- Acceptable wave function: single-valued, finite, continuous, with a continuous first derivative (except where the potential is infinite), and as .
- Superposition holds, and the expectation value of a quantity such as position is .
8.1
(a) Find the de Broglie wavelength of an electron accelerated through . (b) Light of falls on a metal of work function ; find the maximum kinetic energy of the photoelectrons. (c) An electron is located within ; find the minimum uncertainty in its velocity.
(a) de Broglie wavelength:
(b) Photoelectron energy:
(c) Uncertainty in velocity:
(a) ; (b) ; (c) .
8.2 Schrodinger wave equation
8.2.1 Time-dependent and time-independent equations
Schrodinger Equations
For a particle of mass moving in a potential , the time-dependent Schrodinger equation is
When only, separating gives the time-independent equation for stationary states:
In three dimensions . The equation is the quantum counterpart of with .
8.2.2 Probability distribution
The probability of finding the particle between and is . For a stationary state does not depend on time. Conservation of probability is expressed by the continuity equation with probability current .
8.2.3 One-dimensional infinite potential well: particle in a box
A particle is confined to with inside and outside, so .
Particle in a One-Dimensional Box
Inside the box with , so . The condition gives and requires . Therefore
Normalizing, gives :
Energy is quantized and the lowest energy (zero-point energy). The probability density has nodes inside the box, unlike the uniform classical distribution. The levels are spaced as .
8.2.4 Barrier tunnelling: reflection and transmission coefficients
Potential step (). A beam of particles arrives from the left at a step of height . With and , matching and at the step gives
Unlike in classical mechanics, some particles are reflected even when .
Rectangular barrier (). For a barrier of height and width , a classical particle with is always reflected, but the wave function inside the barrier is a decaying exponential with , and a non-zero wave emerges on the far side. This is quantum tunnelling. For a wide barrier () the transmission coefficient is
(the exact result has a prefactor ). falls rapidly with width, with and with . Tunnelling explains -decay, the tunnel diode, field emission and the scanning tunnelling microscope.
8.2
An electron is confined to a one-dimensional box of width . Find (a) the first two energy levels in eV, (b) the wavelength of the photon emitted in the transition, and (c) the probability of finding the electron in the left one-third of the box in the ground state.
(a) Energy levels:
(b) Photon wavelength:
(c) Probability in the left third:
(a) and ; (b) (ultraviolet); (c) .
8.3
(a) Electrons of kinetic energy meet a potential step of . Find and . (b) An electron of energy meets a rectangular barrier of height and width . Estimate the transmission coefficient.
(a) Step: , so .
(b) Barrier:
(a) , ; (b) (about with the exact prefactor ).
Exercises
Practice Exercises — Matter Waves and the Schrodinger Equation
State the de Broglie hypothesis. Find the wavelength of (a) a ball moving at and (b) a thermal neutron at (, ). Why is the wave nature of the ball unobservable?
Hypothesis: Every moving particle has a wave of wavelength .
Numbers:
The ball's wavelength is far smaller than any size or slit it meets, so no diffraction can be seen; the neutron wavelength matches atomic spacings, so crystals diffract it.
; .
State Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. Using it, show that an electron cannot exist inside a nucleus of diameter (estimate its minimum energy using ).
Statement: : position and momentum cannot both be known exactly.
Estimate: With , . The electron is relativistic, so
Beta-decay electrons have only to , so electrons cannot be confined in the nucleus.
Minimum energy , far above observed beta energies, so electrons are not nuclear constituents.
Starting from the time-dependent Schrodinger equation, derive the time-independent equation for a particle of energy in a potential . State the physical meaning of and the conditions for a wave function to be acceptable.
Separation of variables: Put in . Dividing by :
The left side depends on only and the right on only, so both equal a constant . This gives and .
Meaning and conditions: is the probability of finding the particle in . Acceptable is single-valued, finite, continuous with continuous derivative, normalizable and vanishing at infinity.
; is the probability density.
Solve the Schrodinger equation for a particle in a one-dimensional infinite well of width to obtain the energy levels and normalized wave functions. Evaluate , and for an electron in a well of width .
Solution: Inside, with , so (since ). gives , hence . Normalization gives .
Numbers for :
; ; , , .
Distinguish between phase velocity and group velocity, and show that for a relativistic free particle. Find and for a particle moving at .
Definitions: and . For a particle, , , so and .
Relation: From we get , so . Then .
Numbers: and (it carries no energy, so there is no violation of relativity).
; , .