Limit, Continuity, Analytic Functions & Cauchy–Riemann Equations
Open in the Padhaiko app2.0 Complex Numbers
Complex Number, Conjugate and Modulus
A number expressed in the form , where and are real numbers and is the imaginary unit, is called a complex number and is denoted by :
Here is the real part of and is the imaginary part of :
- Complex Conjugate: Two complex numbers and are conjugate to each other. The conjugate of is denoted by .
- Modulus (Absolute Value): The distance from the origin to the point in the complex plane is the non-negative real number
Complex numbers have wide applications across scientific and engineering fields, including signal processing, electromagnetism, fluid dynamics, quantum mechanics, and vibration analysis.
Properties of Complex Numbers
- Property 1 (Equality): If , then ; that is, if , then . Two complex numbers and are equal if and only if
- Property 2 (Sum): The sum of any two complex numbers and is itself a complex number:
- Property 3 (Difference): The difference of any two complex numbers and is itself a complex number:
- Property 4 (Product): The product of any two complex numbers is itself a complex number:
- Property 5 (Quotient): For , the quotient of two complex numbers is itself a complex number:
- Property 6 (Polar Form): Every complex number can be expressed in the polar form
where and the angle is called the amplitude or argument of , written or .
- Property 7 (Exponential Form and Euler's Formulas): Every complex number can be written in exponential form:
With and , we obtain Euler's identities:
- Property 8 (Conjugate Identities): For with conjugate :
- (i) and
- (ii)
- (iii)
- (iv)
- (v)
- (vi) , for
- (vii)
Triangle Inequality
If and are any two complex numbers, then:
- (and hence )
Proof
Let and be represented by the points and in the complex plane, and let represent so that forms a parallelogram with origin . Then , , and .
In the triangle , the length of one side cannot exceed the sum of the other two sides:
Equality holds when the points , , and are collinear. Parts (2) and (3) follow similarly from the triangle relations on .
Powers and Roots of Complex Numbers (De Moivre's Theorem)
For a non-zero complex number , the power is given by for any rational number .
Theorem 1: De Moivre's Theorem
If is a complex number, then for all rational values of ,
Theorem 2: Distinct Roots of a Complex Number
If is a non-zero complex number, then there are and only distinct -th roots of , given by
- Corollary 1: If is a rational fraction in its lowest terms, also has and only distinct values.
- Corollary 2: The distinct -th roots of are given by
Examples on Complex Numbers and Roots (1–6)
1
Express the complex number in form.
Combining over a common denominator: Let . Bringing both fractions over a common denominator:
Simplifying using :
(with , ).
2
Find the locus of when: (i) , and (ii) , where and are constants.
Vector representation in the complex plane: Let and be represented by the points and in the complex plane, with as the origin. Then
Locus for (i) : The condition means the distance is constant. Therefore, the locus of is a circle with centre and radius .
Locus for (ii) : The condition means the directed segment makes a constant angle with the positive -axis. Therefore, the locus of is a straight line (ray) through inclined at an angle to the -axis.
(i) A circle with centre and radius . (ii) A straight line through making an angle with the positive -axis.
3
Find all the values of . Show that the continued product of these roots is .
Converting the base to polar form: Let . Set and , giving
Hence
Applying De Moivre's Theorem for fourth roots: Adding to the argument before taking the power:
Evaluating (1) for :
- For :
- For :
- For :
- For :
Continued product of the four roots:
, , , ; and .
4
Express the following complex numbers in , modulus, and amplitude form: (i) (ii) (iii)
Part (i) : Multiply numerator and denominator by the conjugate :
Its modulus and amplitude are
Part (ii) : In form, and . Using the half-angle identities and :
For , the modulus is and the amplitude is .
Part (iii) : Here and . The modulus and amplitude are
giving the polar form .
(i) , , ; (ii) ; (iii) , , .
5
Find all the values of: (i) (ii) (iii)
Part (i) : Write . By De Moivre's theorem:
Part (ii) : Write . Raising to the third power first gives
Taking the square roots ():
Part (iii) : Write . Raising to the power :
(i) (); (ii) ; (iii) ().
6
If , then show that .
Substituting and factoring : With , we have . Factoring from numerator and denominator:
Applying Euler's identities: Using and :
.
2.1 Complex Functions, Limits, Continuity and Derivatives
Complex Function
Let be a set of complex numbers. A complex function defined on is a rule that assigns to each one or more complex numbers , called the value of at :
- If takes more than one value for a given , it is a multiple-valued function.
- If takes only one value for each , it is a single-valued function.
- The set is the domain of , and the set of all values is the range of .
Writing and , a complex function is equivalent to a pair of real functions of two real variables:
For example, for :
- In Cartesian coordinates: , so and .
- In polar coordinates: , so and .
Limits of a Complex Function
Limit of a Function
Let be a complex function defined in a domain containing a deleted neighbourhood of . We say that tends to the limit as approaches , written
if for every positive number there corresponds a positive number such that
Geometrically, for every -neighbourhood of in the -plane, there is a deleted -neighbourhood of in the -plane whose points map into .
Property 1: Uniqueness of Limit
The limit of a complex function at a point , if it exists, is unique.
Proof
Suppose has two limits and as :
Then for any , there exist and such that
Let . Then for , the triangle inequality gives
Since is a constant and is arbitrary, we must have , or .
Theorem 3: Limit in Terms of Real and Imaginary Parts
Let , , and . Then
Proof
Necessary Condition: Suppose . For each , there exists such that
Since and whenever , we obtain
Sufficient Condition: Conversely, suppose and . For any , there exist such that
Choosing , for we have
Hence .
Theorem 4: Algebraic Operations on Limits
If and , then:
- , provided .
Proof
- Sum: Given , choose so that implies and . Then
- Product: Write
By the triangle inequality,
which can be made smaller than any for .
- Quotient: For ,
for sufficiently small .
Limits Involving the Point at Infinity
- Limit as : if for each there exists such that (i.e. ) implies . Equivalently,
- Infinite Limit at : if for each there exists such that implies (i.e. ). Equivalently,
Continuity and Uniform Continuity
Continuity and Uniform Continuity
- Continuity at a Point: A complex function is continuous at if and both exist and
Equivalently, for each there exists such that .
- Uniform Continuity: A function is uniformly continuous in a region if for every there exists a (depending on only, and not on the individual point) such that for every pair of points ,
Continuity of in a closed and bounded region implies uniform continuity in , whereas continuity at every point of an open region does not necessarily imply uniform continuity in .
Theorem 5: Composition of Continuous Functions
A composition of continuous functions is continuous: if is continuous at and is continuous at , then the composite function is continuous at .
Proof
Since is continuous at , for each there exists such that
Since is continuous at , for this there exists such that
Combining (1) and (2), , so .
Derivatives of Complex Functions
Derivative of a Complex Function
Let be defined in a domain containing a neighbourhood of . Then is differentiable (derivable) at if the limit
exists (where ), independently of the path along which . At a general point ,
Theorem 6: Differentiability Implies Continuity (Converse False)
Differentiability of a complex function at implies continuity at , but the converse is not always true.
Proof
Suppose is differentiable at , so that exists. Writing
and taking the limit as :
Thus is continuous at .
Counterexample for the converse: Consider . Since and are continuous everywhere, is continuous at every point, including . Testing the derivative at :
- Along the real axis (): .
- Along the imaginary axis (): .
Because the limit is not unique, does not exist even though is continuous at .
Theorem 7: Differentiation Rules
If and are differentiable complex functions, then their sum, product, quotient (for ), and composition are also differentiable:
- and for any complex constant
- , for
- Chain Rule: If , then .
Proof
To prove the chain rule at where , note that for sufficiently close to . Hence
Taking the limit as (so by continuity) gives .
2.2 Analytic Functions and Cauchy–Riemann Equations
Analytic, Entire, and Singular Points
- Analytic (Regular / Holomorphic) Function: A single-valued complex function is analytic in a domain if it has a derivative at every point in that domain. A function is analytic at a point if its derivative exists not only at but in some neighbourhood of .
- For example, is not analytic at any point because its derivative exists only at the isolated point .
- Entire (Integral) Function: A function that is differentiable at every point in the entire finite complex plane is called an entire function (e.g., every polynomial , as well as ).
- Singular Point (Singularity): A point at which fails to be analytic, while every neighbourhood of contains at least one point where is analytic, is called a singular point of (e.g., for ).
If and are analytic in a region, then , , (where ), , and rational functions (where ) are also analytic in the region.
Theorem 8: Necessary Conditions for Analyticity (Cauchy–Riemann Equations in Cartesian Form)
If a function is analytic at any point , then the first-order partial derivatives exist and satisfy the Cauchy–Riemann (C–R) equations:
Proof
Since is differentiable at , the limit
exists and is independent of how .
- Along the horizontal path ( wholly real, ):
- Along the vertical path ( wholly imaginary, ):
Since (2) and (3) must be equal, equating real and imaginary parts yields
Corollary: Real and Imaginary Parts Satisfy Laplace's Equation
If a complex-valued function is analytic, then both and satisfy Laplace's equation:
Proof
Since is analytic, and satisfy the Cauchy–Riemann equations
Differentiating (1) partially with respect to and (2) partially with respect to :
Since the partial derivatives of are continuous, . Adding the two equations gives
Similarly, differentiating (1) with respect to and (2) with respect to and adding gives .
Theorem 9: Sufficient Condition for f(z) to be Analytic
If is a continuous single-valued complex function and its first-order partial derivatives are continuous and satisfy the Cauchy–Riemann equations and at each point of a region, then is analytic in that region and
Proof
Let produce increments and in and , so that . Writing
and applying the mean-value theorem with continuous partial derivatives gives, to first order,
Therefore
Substituting the Cauchy–Riemann equations and :
Dividing by and taking the limit as yields
so is analytic.
Cauchy–Riemann Equations in Polar Form
Theorem 10: Cauchy–Riemann Equations in Polar Form
If is analytic at (), then the Cauchy–Riemann equations in polar form are
Furthermore, the derivative is given by:
- Corollary 1:
- Corollary 2:
Proof
Substituting into gives
Differentiating (1) partially with respect to and :
Equating the right-hand sides of (2) and (3) and matching real and imaginary parts gives
For Corollary 1, using and , we have and . By the chain rule:
Substituting and gives
For Corollary 2, substituting and instead yields
| Aspect | Cartesian Form () | Polar Form () |
|---|---|---|
| Cauchy–Riemann equations | ||
| Derivative | ||
| Best suited for | Polynomials, , , | Powers , , , fractional powers |
Circular, Exponential, and Hyperbolic Functions
For a complex variable , the exponential and circular functions are defined by their power series:
Combining and yields , and hence
The complex hyperbolic functions are defined by
with , , and .
Properties I & II: Relations Between Circular and Hyperbolic Functions
For any complex variable :
- Property I: and
- Property II: and
Proof
- Replacing by in and :
- Replacing by in and :
Worked Out Examples (1–12)
1
Separate into real and imaginary parts of the following functions: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv)
Part (i) : Multiply numerator and denominator of by :
Equating real and imaginary parts gives
Part (ii) : Multiply numerator and denominator of by :
Equating real and imaginary parts gives
Part (iii) : Multiply numerator and denominator of by :
Hence and .
Part (iv) : Multiply numerator and denominator of by :
Hence and .
(i) , ; (ii) , ; (iii) , ; (iv) , .
2
Separate into real and imaginary parts of the following functions: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv)
Part (i) :
giving and .
Part (ii) :
giving and .
Part (iii) :
giving and .
Part (iv) : Write
Adding (1) and (2):
Subtracting (2) from (1):
(i) , ; (ii) , ; (iii) , ; (iv) , .
3
If in the open disk , show that .
Bounding : The point lies on the boundary of the open disk . For any and in the disk with :
Choosing in terms of : Choosing , we have
Thus the - definition of the limit is satisfied, and .
With , , proving .
4
If , show that .
Evaluating the limit as : We have
- Along the horizontal path , :
- Along the vertical path , :
Conclusion by Theorem 3: Since and , the limit exists and equals .
.
5
Consider the function and discuss .
Setting up the difference quotient: Let . Then
Dividing by and taking the limit as :
Checking the limit along different paths:
- Along the real axis ():
- Along the imaginary axis ():
- Along the line ():
In fact, since , the ratio is identically for every non-zero , so is differentiable everywhere with .
is differentiable everywhere with .
6
Show that is differentiable only at the origin.
Separating real and imaginary parts: Write
so and .
Applying the Cauchy–Riemann equations: Computing the first-order partial derivatives:
For to be differentiable at , the Cauchy–Riemann equations must hold:
Since all four partial derivatives are continuous everywhere, is differentiable only at the origin (and hence is nowhere analytic).
The Cauchy–Riemann equations and hold only at , so is differentiable only at the origin.
7
Show that is analytic.
Separating real and imaginary parts:
Thus and .
Verifying the Cauchy–Riemann equations: Differentiating partially with respect to and :
Since the partial derivatives are continuous everywhere and , , is analytic everywhere.
Since and are continuous everywhere, is analytic.
8
Show that is not analytic.
Separating real and imaginary parts:
so and .
Checking the Cauchy–Riemann equations: For , differentiating partially with respect to and :
For , (unless ) and requires , which cannot hold simultaneously in any open neighbourhood. Hence is not analytic anywhere.
The Cauchy–Riemann equations fail at all non-zero points, so is nowhere analytic.
9
Show that the function is analytic except at the origin.
Writing in polar form: For , De Moivre's theorem gives
so and .
Verifying the polar Cauchy–Riemann equations: Differentiating partially with respect to and for :
These partial derivatives are continuous for and satisfy
Hence is analytic everywhere except at (where fails to exist).
The polar Cauchy–Riemann equations hold for all , so is analytic everywhere except at .
10
Show that the function is analytic except at .
Polar representation for : Setting with , De Moivre's theorem gives
so and .
Verifying the polar Cauchy–Riemann equations: Differentiating partially with respect to and :
Thus and are satisfied for all , so is analytic except at .
satisfies the polar Cauchy–Riemann equations for all , so it is analytic everywhere except at .
11
Show that the function , where is any positive integer, is analytic.
Polar representation: Write , so
Verifying the polar Cauchy–Riemann equations: Differentiating with respect to and :
Since and hold with continuous partial derivatives, is analytic everywhere.
Since and , is analytic everywhere.
12
Show that the function is not analytic at the origin although the Cauchy–Riemann equations are satisfied at the origin.
Testing differentiability at the origin: Here , so and . By the definition of the derivative at :
- Along the straight line (, ):
which depends on the slope .
- Along the real axis ():
Since the limit depends on the path of approach, does not exist and is not analytic at the origin.
Verifying the Cauchy–Riemann equations at the origin: Using the limit definition of partial derivatives at :
Hence and at , so the Cauchy–Riemann equations are satisfied at the origin even though is not differentiable there.
At , so the C–R equations hold, but along the difference quotient tends to (path-dependent), so does not exist.
Exercise - 5
Exercise - 5
Find the real and imaginary parts of .
Expanding in Cartesian form: Let , where . Using Euler's formula:
Identifying the real and imaginary parts: Comparing :
Thus the real and imaginary parts are and .
Find the real and imaginary parts of .
Expanding with : Using the addition formula for cosine:
Using the hyperbolic identities and :
Identifying the real and imaginary parts: Comparing with :
Thus the real and imaginary parts are and .
Find the real and imaginary parts of .
Expanding with : Using the addition formula for sine:
Using and :
Identifying the real and imaginary parts: Comparing with :
Thus the real and imaginary parts are and .
Find the real and imaginary parts of .
Expanding with : Using the addition identity for hyperbolic sine:
Using the relations and :
Identifying the real and imaginary parts: Comparing with :
Thus the real and imaginary parts are and .
Find the real and imaginary parts of , .
Expressing in terms of : Write . Then , so:
Multiply numerator and denominator by the complex conjugate :
Simplifying the denominator: Using and :
Separating real and imaginary parts: Substituting the simplified denominator:
Thus the real and imaginary parts are:
Find the real and imaginary parts of .
Writing in polar form: Let , where and . Then . Taking the quotient:
Thus and .
Evaluating : Applying the definition of the complex logarithm :
The real part is and the imaginary part is . (The textbook printed answer lists as the real part, which is , alongside imaginary part ).
Printed: .
Show that is an analytic function.
Separating real and imaginary parts: Let . Then
Thus and .
Evaluating first-order partial derivatives: Differentiating and with respect to and :
Verifying the Cauchy–Riemann equations: Comparing the partial derivatives:
The partial derivatives exist and are continuous everywhere in the complex plane, and they satisfy the Cauchy–Riemann equations at every point. Therefore, is analytic throughout (an entire function).
Proof verification (, satisfy and ).
Show that is an analytic function.
Identifying and : From , we have:
(Note that ).
Computing partial derivatives: Differentiating with respect to and :
Checking the Cauchy–Riemann equations: We see that:
Since all four partial derivatives are continuous everywhere in the plane and satisfy the Cauchy–Riemann equations at all points, is analytic everywhere.
Proof verification (; and ).
Show that is an analytic function and find its derivative.
Separating real and imaginary parts: We have with:
Verifying analyticity via Cauchy–Riemann equations: Computing the partial derivatives:
Thus:
Since the partial derivatives are continuous everywhere and satisfy the Cauchy–Riemann equations, is analytic everywhere.
Finding the derivative: By the formula for the derivative of an analytic function:
Show that is an analytic function and find its derivative.
Expanding into real and imaginary parts: Let . Then
Thus and .
Verifying the Cauchy–Riemann equations: Differentiating:
Comparing:
Since all four partial derivatives are continuous polynomials and satisfy the Cauchy–Riemann equations everywhere, is analytic everywhere.
Evaluating the derivative: Using :
Show that is an analytic function everywhere except .
Writing in polar coordinates: In polar form, where and . Then:
Comparing with in polar form:
Computing partial derivatives in polar form: Differentiating with respect to and :
Checking Cauchy–Riemann equations in polar form: The polar Cauchy–Riemann equations are:
For all (i.e., ), all partial derivatives exist, are continuous, and satisfy the Cauchy–Riemann equations. At , , so is undefined. Therefore, is analytic everywhere except .
Proof verification (in polar form ; and for ).
If and are functions of and satisfying Laplace's equation, then show that is an analytic function where and .
Given conditions on and : Since and satisfy Laplace's equation:
Checking the first Cauchy–Riemann equation for and : We are given and . Differentiating:
Assuming equality of mixed partials ():
Checking the second Cauchy–Riemann equation: Differentiating with respect to and with respect to :
Adding the two:
Since and satisfy the Cauchy–Riemann equations and and their partial derivatives are continuous, is an analytic function.
Proof verification ( and ).
Show that is not an analytic function.
Identifying real and imaginary parts: For , we have:
Computing partial derivatives and testing Cauchy–Riemann equations: Evaluating the first-order partial derivatives:
For the Cauchy–Riemann equations to hold:
Concluding lack of analyticity: The Cauchy–Riemann equations hold only at the isolated point . Since analyticity requires to be differentiable in an open neighborhood of a point, and no such neighborhood exists where C–R equations hold, is not an analytic function.
Proof verification ( and except at ).
Show that is not an analytic function.
Separating real and imaginary parts: Let . Then
Thus and .
Evaluating partial derivatives for : For :
The Cauchy–Riemann equations require , and , which contradicts .
Testing differentiability at : At , the difference quotient is:
- Along the positive real axis (): the limit is .
- Along the positive imaginary axis (): the limit is .
Since the limit depends on the path, does not exist. Thus is nowhere differentiable and hence not an analytic function.
Proof verification (; and for ).
Show that is not an analytic function.
Writing in Cartesian form: Let , so . Then:
Thus and .
Computing partial derivatives: Differentiating with respect to and :
Checking the Cauchy–Riemann equations: For the first C–R equation:
Since , this requires . For the second C–R equation:
Since and cannot hold simultaneously (as ), the Cauchy–Riemann equations are nowhere satisfied. Therefore, is not an analytic function.
Proof verification (; ).
Determine whether is analytic.
Separating into real and imaginary parts: Let . Then
So and .
Verifying the Cauchy–Riemann equations: Computing the partial derivatives:
We have and . Since all four partial derivatives are continuous everywhere in , the Cauchy–Riemann equations are satisfied everywhere. Thus is an entire (analytic) function.
Analytic
Determine whether is analytic.
Separating real and imaginary parts: Let . Then
Thus and .
Testing the Cauchy–Riemann equations: Computing the partial derivatives:
The Cauchy–Riemann equations require:
These hold only at the single isolated point . Because there is no open neighborhood in which the function is differentiable, is not analytic.
Not analytic
Determine whether is analytic.
Checking differentiability: For any , the function has derivative:
Since exists at every point in the domain , is analytic everywhere except at , where the function has an isolated pole.
Analytic except
Determine whether is analytic.
Simplifying : Let . Then , so
Thus and .
Testing the Cauchy–Riemann equations: Evaluating the partial derivatives:
Checking the first C–R equation:
which is a contradiction everywhere. Since the Cauchy–Riemann equations fail at all points in , is not analytic.
Not analytic
Determine whether is analytic.
Identifying real and imaginary parts: Let . Then
Testing the Cauchy–Riemann equations: Computing the partial derivatives:
Comparing them:
The Cauchy–Riemann equations hold only at . Since there is no open domain where they hold, is not analytic. (The printed answer erroneously states "Analytic", which would apply to the conjugate expression ).
Printed: Analytic.
Determine whether is analytic.
Expressing the function in terms of and its components: We have:
Here and .
Evaluating partial derivatives: Computing the partial derivatives for :
Thus . Similarly and , so . These equations hold only along isolated lines and not on any open disk, so is not analytic anywhere.
As explained in the erratum, the intended standard function is , which is analytic everywhere except , giving the printed answer.
Printed: Analytic except .
Find the point where Cauchy–Riemann equations are satisfied for the function .
Identifying real and imaginary parts: For , we have:
Computing partial derivatives: Differentiating and with respect to and :
Solving the Cauchy–Riemann equations: The Cauchy–Riemann equations are:
From (2), either or :
- If , then from (1), .
- If , then from (1), .
Therefore, the only point where both equations are satisfied simultaneously is .