Past exam question: 2071 Chaitra, Q6
Open in the Padhaiko appQuestion
Compare the transmission characteristics and performance (frequency range, bandwidth, security, flexibility, interference, connectivity) of Optical fiber cable and Satellite transmission.
Solution
Comprehensive Comparison Table:
| Characteristic / Parameter | Optical Fiber Cable (Guided Media) | Satellite Transmission (Unguided Media) |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Frequency Range / Spectrum | Infrared light spectrum: to (wavelengths ). | Microwave RF bands: to (C-band: 4/6 GHz, Ku-band: 11/14 GHz, Ka-band: 20/30 GHz). |
| 2. Usable Bandwidth | Enormous (tens of Terahertz per strand); DWDM provides multi-Tbps per cable. | Moderate (typically 500 MHz to a few GHz per transponder). |
| 3. Propagation Delay (Latency) | Very low: ( trans-continental round trip). | High for GEO: one-way ( round trip due to orbital altitude). |
| 4. Security and Eavesdropping | Extremely high: light stays confined inside core; physical tapping is difficult and easily detected by optical loss. | Lower security: broadcast downlink footprint covers entire continents; susceptible to eavesdropping without encryption. |
| 5. Flexibility and Mobility | Low flexibility: requires physical trenching, ducts, rights-of-way; fixed endpoint connectivity only. | Very high: instant global coverage; supports mobile terminals (ships, aircraft, remote expeditions). |
| 6. Environmental Interference | Immune to electromagnetic interference (EMI), radio frequency interference (RFI), and lightning. | Susceptible to atmospheric attenuation, solar flares, rain fade (especially in Ku/Ka bands), and cosmic noise. |
| 7. Connectivity Topology | Point-to-point physical links interconnected via switches and routers. | Inherent point-to-multipoint broadcast capability over vast geographic footprints. |
Answer:
Optical fiber offers far higher bandwidth, minimal attenuation, complete EMI immunity, and high physical security over point-to-point guided links, whereas satellite transmission operates in microwave bands with inherent wide-area broadcast connectivity and mobile flexibility at the cost of higher latency, atmospheric attenuation, and shared wireless interception risk.