Past exam question: 2076 Ashwin, Q9(c)
Open in the Padhaiko appQuestion
Write short note on: Optical fiber versus STP
Solution
Comparison Between Optical Fiber Cable and Shielded Twisted Pair (STP):
| Feature | Optical Fiber Cable | Shielded Twisted Pair (STP) |
|---|---|---|
| Transmission Mechanism | Light photons via total internal reflection | Electrical current / voltage in copper conductors |
| Bandwidth & Data Rate | Extremely high ( per wavelength, multi-THz optical window) | Moderate (up to on Cat6A/Cat7 over short reach) |
| Attenuation & Distance | Ultra-low ( in single-mode; spans tens of km without repeaters) | High copper attenuation; limited to per segment |
| EMI / RFI Immunity | immune (dielectric glass is unaffected by electromagnetic fields or lightning) | Good immunity due to foil/braid shield, but susceptible if shield is ungrounded |
| Security & Tapping | High (virtually impossible to tap without detection; no RF emission) | Vulnerable to inductive electromagnetic eavesdropping |
| Weight & Installation | Lightweight, thin, but requires specialized fusion splicing and optical transceivers | Bulky, rigid, heavier, but uses standard RJ-45 crimping |
Answer:
Optical fiber transmits light through glass cores, offering massive bandwidth, ultra-low attenuation (), long reach (), and total immunity to EMI and electrical surges. STP transmits electrical signals over shielded copper pairs, suitable for short distances () with moderate EMI protection, but suffers from higher attenuation and strict grounding requirements.