Brazing and Soldering
Open in the Padhaiko app8.1 Brazing
Brazing is a metal-joining process in which two closely fitted workpieces are heated to a suitable temperature and joined by melting a non-ferrous filler metal whose liquidus temperature is above 450 deg C (typically 600–900 deg C) yet strictly below the melting point (solidus) of the base metals. The molten filler is drawn smoothly throughout the narrow gap by capillary action and bonds metallurgically upon solidification without melting the parent parts.
Brazing Equipment and Materials
- Heating Equipment (Brazing Methods):
- Torch Brazing: Uses an oxyacetylene, oxy-LPG, or air-gas blowpipe torch; flexible for workshop repairs and small batches.
- Furnace Brazing: Assemblies pre-loaded with paste/foil filler are heated uniformly in a controlled-atmosphere electric or gas furnace (requires little or no flux).
- Induction & Resistance Brazing: High-frequency copper induction coils or carbon resistance jaws localize rapid heat cleanly to the joint zone.
- Dip Brazing: Immersion into a molten chemical salt bath or molten brazing alloy bath.
- Brazing Filler Metals (Spelters):
- Copper–Zinc (Brass Spelter, ~60% Cu / 40% Zn): Melts around 880–900 deg C; strong economical joints on mild steel, cast iron, and copper.
- Silver Alloys (Silver Solder, Ag–Cu–Zn–Cd/Sn): Melts lower at 620–780 deg C; high fluidity, ductility, and strength for dissimilar metals, stainless steel, copper, and brass.
- Copper–Phosphorus Alloys: Melts at ~710–800 deg C; self-fluxing on copper-to-copper joints (never use on steel/nickel due to brittle phosphides).
- Aluminium–Silicon Alloys: Melts at 570–620 deg C for brazing aluminium alloys.
- Brazing Fluxes: Applied as paste or powder to dissolve surface oxides and protect heated faces—borax (sodium tetraborate) or borax + boric acid (active 750–1000 deg C) for brass spelters; fluoride–borate pastes (active 550–800 deg C) for silver brazing; chloride–fluoride fluxes for aluminium.
Brazing Process Preparation: Surface Cleaning, Joint Design, and Supporting Parts
- Surface Cleaning (Syllabus: "surface clearing"): Capillary flow fails completely on oil, paint, grease, rust, or scale. Clean mating faces mechanically (emery cloth, steel wool, wire brush, or grit blasting) and degrease chemically (acetone, alkaline cleaner, or acid pickling) immediately prior to fluxing; avoid touching cleaned areas with bare fingers.
- Joint Design (Syllabus: "join design"):
- Avoid pure butt joints (small area, sensitive to bending). Use lap joints or scarf joints so loads pass primarily in shear.
- Standard lap overlap rule: Overlap length L >= 3t to 4t (where t = thickness of the thinner member) ensures the brazed joint is stronger than the base metal.
- Maintain a tight radial/flat joint clearance of 0.025 to 0.15 mm (optimal 0.05–0.10 mm). Too wide loses capillary suction; too tight starves filler entry.
- Supporting Parts: Hold components rigidly without slipping during thermal expansion using self-jigging features (knurling, crimping, shoulder steps, press fits), stainless-steel/ceramic fixtures, counterweights, or small tack welds. Keep heavy steel clamps away from the joint seam so they do not act as heat sinks.
Brazing Operations (Heating, Flux Application, Filler Metal Application, Cleaning After Brazing)
- Flux Application: Brush a thin, uniform coat of paste flux over both cleaned joint faces before assembly, plus a light coat along the outside seam and filler rod tip.
- Heating: Adjust a torch to a neutral or slightly carburizing (reducing) flame (to avoid oxidizing the metal). Move the flame smoothly in broad sweeps across the thicker/heavier workpiece section first so both parts reach brazing temperature together—never focus a sharp flame cone on one spot or directly onto the filler rod. When the flux turns clear, thin, and glassy, the metal is at brazing temperature.
- Filler Metal Application: Touch the end of the brazing rod to the edge of the heated joint gap while keeping the base metal warm. Conduction from the hot base metal melts the rod, and capillary action pulls molten filler rapidly through the entire overlap until a smooth fillet shows on the opposite edge. Remove heat immediately once filled.
- Cleaning After Brazing (Syllabus: "clearing after brazing"): Let the assembly cool below ~300 deg C until the filler solidifies completely without disturbing it, then scrub off all hardened glass-like flux residue with hot water and a stiff brush (or weak acid pickle) and dry thoroughly—residual borate/fluoride flux attracts moisture and corrodes the joint over time.
8.2 Soldering
Soldering (Soft Soldering) joins metal surfaces by melting a low-temperature filler alloy (soft solder) whose melting point is below 450 deg C (typically 180–250 deg C), relying on surface wetting and capillary action without melting the base metals. Soldering provides moderate mechanical strength and high electrical/thermal conductivity—making it essential in electrical/electronic wiring, PCB assembly, sheet-metal tinware, and copper plumbing.
Soldering Flux
Soldering temperatures are far too low to burn away oxide films by flame alone, so flux is indispensable to:
- Chemically dissolve thin surface oxides (copper oxide, iron oxide, zinc oxide),
- Shield heated metal from atmospheric oxygen during soldering, and
- Lower molten solder surface tension so solder wets and spreads evenly.
| Flux Category | Common Examples | Characteristics & Applications |
|---|---|---|
| Corrosive (Active / Acid) Fluxes | Zinc chloride ("killed spirits"), ammonium chloride (sal ammoniac), hydrochloric acid | Aggressively cleans steel, galvanized iron, brass, and copper sheets; must be washed clean immediately after soldering to prevent corrosion. NEVER use on electrical/electronic circuits |
| Mildly Active (Organic) Fluxes | Oleic acid, stearic acid, tallow, lactic acid | Moderate cleaning on copper/brass/lead; milder than chlorides, still cleaned afterward |
| Non-Corrosive (Rosin) Fluxes | Pine rosin, rosin-alcohol paste, rosin-cored solder wire | Active only when heated; leaves an insulating, non-corrosive residue—standard for electrical joints and electronic PCBs |
Soft Solders
| Solder Alloy Composition | Melting Temperature | Key Properties & Primary Uses |
|---|---|---|
| 63% Tin (Sn) / 37% Lead (Pb) (Eutectic) | 183 deg C (sharp single point) | Transitions instantly from liquid to solid with no pasty zone; ideal for precision electronics and PCBs |
| 60% Sn / 40% Pb | 183–190 deg C | Narrow pasty range, bright smooth joints; general electrical & electronic soldering |
| 50% Sn / 50% Pb (Half-and-half) | 183–216 deg C | Good wetting and gap filling; sheet-metal seams (tinplate, GI), radiators, brass work |
| 40% Sn / 60% Pb (Plumber's solder) | 183–238 deg C | Wide pasty range allowing wiped plumbing/lead cable joints to be shaped with a cloth |
| 96.5% Sn / 3.0% Ag / 0.5% Cu (SAC305 Lead-Free) | 217–220 deg C | RoHS-compliant lead-free electronics and safe potable water copper piping |
Soldering Process (Step-by-Step)
- Surface Cleaning: Scrape, file, or abrade joint surfaces with emery paper until bright bare metal shows, then wipe free of oil and fingerprints.
- Preparing and Tinning the Soldering Bit: Heat the copper soldering iron bit (electric iron 250–350 C, or furnace-heated hatchet iron) to working temperature, clean the copper tip briefly, dip in flux/sal ammoniac, and melt a thin bright film of solder onto the tip (tinning) so heat transfers rapidly into the joint.
- Fit-up and Fluxing: Position parts tightly (0.05–0.15 mm clearance) and brush matching flux onto the joint area (or use rosin-core wire for electronics).
- Heating and Applying Solder: Hold the flat face of the tinned soldering iron firmly against both metal parts at the joint for 1–3 seconds until they reach solder melting temperature, then feed solder wire onto the heated seam (opposite the iron tip) so capillary wetting pulls solder cleanly across the joint.
- Solidification Without Movement: Withdraw the solder wire, then slide the iron away smoothly. Keep the joint completely motionless until the solder solidifies from bright liquid to sheen—disturbing a cooling joint creates a dull, grainy, high-resistance "cold solder joint".
- Post-Solder Cleaning: Wash off any acid/chloride flux residue thoroughly with warm water and detergent/alcohol; inspect for a smooth, bright, concave fillet.
| Feature | Welding (Fusion) | Brazing | Soldering (Soft) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base Metal Melting | Yes (parent edges melt and fuse) | No (base metals stay solid) | No (base metals stay solid) |
| Filler Melting Temp | Similar to base metal (~1400–1550 C for steel) | Above 450 deg C (typically 600–900 C) | Below 450 deg C (typically 180–250 C) |
| Filler Metal | Same composition as base metal (or omitted) | Copper-zinc (brass), silver, Cu-P, Al-Si alloys | Tin-lead (Sn-Pb) or lead-free Sn-Ag-Cu alloys |
| Primary Bonding Action | Metallurgical fusion & solidification | Capillary action + surface alloying | Capillary action + wetting/adhesion |
| Typical Fluxes | Electrode coating / gas welding borax | Borax, boric acid, fluorides | Zinc chloride (sheet metal) / Rosin (electronics) |
| Joint Strength | Highest (equal to or stronger than base metal) | High (stronger than solder; good for steel/Cu/dissimilar) | Low-to-moderate (electrical & light sealing/sheet seams) |
Worked Examples
1
Two 2.5 mm thick mild steel strips of width w = 25 mm are joined by a brazed lap joint using a brass spelter (allowable shear strength of brazed joint = 110 MPa; tensile strength of mild steel strip = 150 MPa). (a) Using the 4t overlap rule, calculate the recommended lap length (L). (b) Compare the shear load capacity of the brazed lap joint against the tensile load capacity of the steel strip to verify that the joint will not fail before the parent strip. (c) Compute the volume of molten filler metal (in cu mm) needed to fill the lap gap if the joint clearance is 0.08 mm (ignoring external fillet).
(a) Calculate recommended lap overlap length (L = 4t):
- Strip thickness t = 2.5 mm.
- Lap overlap length L = 4 x t = 4 x 2.5 = 10.0 mm.
(b) Compare joint shear capacity vs. parent strip tensile capacity:
- Parent steel strip tensile capacity: F_strip = sigma_steel x (w x t) = 150 N/sq mm x (25 x 2.5) = 150 x 62.5 = 9375 N (9.375 kN).
- Brazed lap shear capacity: F_joint = tau_braze x (w x L) = 110 N/sq mm x (25 x 10.0) = 110 x 250 = 27500 N (27.5 kN).
- Since 27500 N > 9375 N (almost 3x margin), the parent strip reaches yield/failure long before the brazed seam shears.
(c) Calculate filler volume inside the 0.08 mm clearance:
- Filler volume = Overlap area x Clearance = (25 x 10.0) x 0.08 = 250 x 0.08 = 20.0 cu mm.
(a) Lap length L = 10.0 mm; (b) Joint shear capacity (27500 N) exceeds parent strip tensile capacity (9375 N); (c) Required gap filler volume = 20.0 cu mm.
2
(a) A 1.5 mm thick, 50 mm wide tinplate sheet is soft-soldered into a lap seam with an overlap of 8 x t using 50/50 Sn–Pb solder (allowable shear stress = 25 MPa). Calculate the lap length (L) and the maximum shear load (N) the soldered seam can carry. (b) A 60 W electric soldering iron stays plugged in for 5 minutes (300 s) during a lab session. Calculate the electrical energy consumed in Joules (kJ) and state which solder alloy (63/37 Sn–Pb, 50/50 Sn–Pb, or SAC305) is best for soldering a delicate PCB IC pin and why.
(a) Calculate lap length and maximum shear load of the soldered seam:
- Lap length: L = 8 x t = 8 x 1.5 = 12.0 mm.
- Soldered shear area: A = w x L = 50 x 12.0 = 600 sq mm.
- Maximum shear load: F = tau x A = 25 N/sq mm x 600 sq mm = 15000 N (15.0 kN).
(b) Energy consumed and solder selection for PCB work:
- Electrical energy consumed: E = Power x Time = 60 W x 300 s = 18000 J (18.0 kJ).
- Best PCB alloy: 63% Sn / 37% Pb (eutectic solder) melts at the lowest, single sharp temperature (183 deg C) with zero pasty transition—minimizing heat exposure to delicate semiconductor pins and avoiding cold solder joints (use SAC305 at 217–220 deg C if lead-free compliance is required).
(a) Lap length = 12.0 mm, maximum shear load = 15000 N (15.0 kN); (b) Energy = 18000 J (18.0 kJ); select 63/37 eutectic Sn–Pb (183 deg C sharp melting point) for delicate PCB pins (or SAC305 if lead-free).
3
Describe the complete ordered workshop procedure to torch-braze a brass-spelter lap joint between two 2 mm thick mild steel plates (10 mm overlap), highlighting surface preparation, clearance, support, fluxing, heating, filler feeding, and post-braze cleaning.
Surface cleaning, joint fit-up, and supporting parts:
- Grind/sand both overlapping faces with emery cloth to bright bare steel and wipe clean with acetone to remove oil and fingerprints.
- Position the plates in a 10 mm lap (5t > 3t) with a uniform 0.05–0.10 mm gap (using thin shim/knurl spacing if tightly clamped) and support both pieces level on firebricks using steel/stainless clamps positioned well away from the overlap seam.
Flux application, torch heating, filler feeding, and post-braze cleaning:
- Brush borax paste flux evenly onto both mating surfaces before clamping and along the exposed seam edges.
- Light an oxyacetylene torch and adjust to a neutral or slightly carburizing flame. Sweep the flame broadly across the mild steel around the overlap until the steel glows cherry red (~850–900 deg C) and the borax flux melts into a clear liquid film.
- Touch the 60/40 brass brazing rod (pre-dipped in borax flux) to the seam edge—heat from the glowing steel melts the rod and capillary action pulls molten brass across the entire 10 mm lap until a continuous golden fillet appears along the opposite edge.
- Remove the flame, wait without disturbing the plates until the filler solidifies and cools below ~300 deg C, then wash and wire-brush thoroughly in hot water to strip all glassy borax flux residue and inspect the finished fillet.
- Abrade & degrease surfaces -> 2. Fix 10 mm lap (0.05–0.10 mm gap) on firebricks with clamps away from seam -> 3. Coat with borax paste flux -> 4. Heat evenly with neutral/slightly carburizing flame to cherry red until flux turns glassy -> 5. Touch brass rod to seam so capillary action draws filler through -> 6. Cool undisturbed, then scrub flux off in hot water.
Exercises
added
Two 3.0 mm thick copper plates of width 30 mm are to be joined using a brazed lap joint. (a) Calculate the minimum and upper recommended lap overlap lengths using the 3t to 4t design rule. (b) Using the 4t overlap length and an optimal joint clearance of 0.10 mm, calculate the volume of silver brazing alloy (in cu mm) needed to fill the lap gap.
(a) Compute recommended lap overlap lengths:
- Plate thickness t = 3.0 mm.
- Minimum overlap (3t) = 3 x 3.0 = 9.0 mm.
- Upper recommended overlap (4t) = 4 x 3.0 = 12.0 mm.
(b) Compute silver filler metal volume inside the gap:
- Overlap area (using L = 12.0 mm, width w = 30 mm) = 30 x 12.0 = 360 sq mm.
- Gap volume = Area x Clearance = 360 x 0.10 = 36.0 cu mm.
(a) Recommended lap overlap = 9.0 mm to 12.0 mm; (b) Filler volume in 0.10 mm gap = 36.0 cu mm.
A 1.2 mm thick, 40 mm wide brass strip (tensile strength 180 MPa) is joined by a soft-soldered lap joint with a 15 mm overlap using 50/50 tin-lead solder (allowable shear strength 28 MPa). (a) Calculate the shear load capacity of the soldered lap joint and compare it with the tensile capacity of the brass strip. (b) State why soft-soldered joints in sheet metal often use much wider overlaps (10–15 mm) or mechanical lock seams compared to brazed joints.
(a) Compute soldered shear capacity vs. brass tensile capacity:
- Soldered lap area: A_solder = 40 x 15 = 600 sq mm.
- Soldered shear capacity: F_solder = 28 x 600 = 16800 N (16.8 kN).
- Brass strip cross-section: A_brass = 40 x 1.2 = 48 sq mm.
- Brass tensile capacity: F_brass = 180 x 48 = 8640 N (8.64 kN).
- Thus the 15 mm overlap gives the soldered joint nearly double the tensile capacity of the thin strip.
(b) Why soldered joints need larger overlaps or lock seams: Because soft Sn–Pb solder has low shear strength (~20–30 MPa compared to 100–200 MPa for brass/silver brazing alloys) and softens further at modest temperatures, engineers use wide overlaps (10–15 mm) or interlocked grooved/folded seams sealed by solder for liquid tightness.
(a) Soldered shear capacity = 16800 N (16.8 kN) vs. brass tensile capacity = 8640 N (8.64 kN); (b) Wide overlaps or folded seams compensate for soft solder's much lower shear strength (~28 MPa).
Compare welding, brazing, and soldering in tabular or point form covering: (a) filler melting temperature relative to 450 deg C, (b) whether the base metal melts, (c) bonding mechanism, (d) typical filler metals and fluxes, and (e) joint strength.
Compare the three joining processes across all five criteria:
- (a) Temperature: Welding melts base metal (~1400–1550 C for steel); Brazing uses filler melting above 450 deg C (600–900 C); Soldering uses filler melting below 450 deg C (180–250 C).
- (b) Base metal melting: Melts in welding; stays completely solid in both brazing and soldering.
- (c) Bonding mechanism: Welding relies on fusion/coalescence; brazing and soldering rely on capillary action and wetting.
- (d) Fillers & fluxes: Welding uses matching rods + electrode/borax flux; brazing uses brass/silver/Cu-P/Al-Si fillers + borax/fluoride flux; soldering uses Sn-Pb or Sn-Ag-Cu alloys + zinc chloride (sheet metal) or rosin (electronics).
- (e) Joint strength: Highest in welding, high in brazing, low-to-moderate in soldering.
Welding (base metal melts, highest strength); Brazing (filler > 450 C, base solid, capillary action, brass/silver + borax, high strength); Soldering (filler < 450 C, base solid, capillary action, Sn-Pb/SAC + rosin or ZnCl2, light mechanical/electrical joints).
Explain the importance of surface cleaning, joint clearance (0.025–0.15 mm), and post-brazing flux removal in brazing. Why are lap or scarf joints preferred over butt joints in brazed assemblies?
Surface cleaning, joint clearance, and post-braze flux removal:
- Surface cleaning: Oil, grease, paint, and oxide scales break surface wetting and block capillary action, leaving voids and weak unbrazed patches.
- Joint clearance (0.025–0.15 mm): Capillary suction is inversely proportional to gap width—if the gap is too wide, molten filler runs straight through without filling; if zero-gap tight, molten filler cannot enter.
- Post-brazing cleaning: Leftover borax/fluoride flux is hygroscopic and corrosive; washing with hot water and wire brushing prevents long-term joint corrosion and crack initiation.
Why lap or scarf joints are preferred over butt joints: A butt joint limits the bond area to the cross-sectional thickness of the plates and suffers severe tensile/bending stress concentration. A lap or scarf joint (overlap >= 3t to 4t) places the thin filler film in shear over a large surface area so the joint exceeds the strength of the base metal.
Cleaning removes oils/oxides so capillary wetting occurs; 0.025–0.15 mm clearance maximizes capillary draw; post-braze washing removes corrosive flux residue. Lap/scarf joints (overlap >= 3t–4t) provide a large shear area stronger than the parent plate, unlike weak small-area butt joints.
Distinguish between corrosive (acid) and non-corrosive (rosin) soldering fluxes, stating where each must and must not be used. Also explain why 63% Sn / 37% Pb is called a eutectic solder and describe what causes a cold solder joint.
Corrosive vs. Non-corrosive fluxes:
- Corrosive fluxes (zinc chloride, sal ammoniac): Strongly remove tough oxides on galvanized iron, mild steel, and heavy copper/brass sheets, but leave conductive acidic residues that corrode copper wires rapidly—must be washed after soldering and never used on electronics.
- Non-corrosive fluxes (pine rosin): Activate only at soldering heat to clean copper/tinned leads and solidify into an inert insulating film—safe and standard for electrical and PCB soldering.
Eutectic solder (63/37 Sn–Pb) and cold solder joints:
- 63% Sn / 37% Pb eutectic solder has a single sharp melting/freezing temperature of 183 deg C (no slushy/pasty solid-liquid mushy range), allowing instant solidification with clean fillets.
- Cold solder joint: Occurs when the parts were insufficiently heated (solder melted only on the iron tip, not on the joint), flux was missing/dirty, or the parts moved during solidification, producing a dull, crumbly, high-resistance joint prone to mechanical failure.
Corrosive fluxes (ZnCl2) clean steel/GI sheets (wash after use; never on electronics); rosin fluxes are non-conductive/non-corrosive for PCBs. 63/37 Sn–Pb is eutectic because it melts/freezes sharply at 183 deg C with no pasty zone. A cold solder joint results from insufficient heating, poor cleaning, or disturbing the joint while cooling.